

Indiana Real Estate Broker
Carrie Nichols is a top-producing real estate professional serving Northwest Indiana, recognized for her results-driven approach, strong market expertise, and commitment to putting her clients first. With several years of experience and nearly $15 million in annual sales volume, she ranks among the top 2% of agents in the state.
As a Listing Specialist for The Jana Caudill Team, Carrie plays a vital role in representing sellers at a high level . Her association with one of Northwest Indiana’s leading real estate teams has further sharpened her skills in pricing strategy, marketing, and negotiation, allowing her to deliver even greater value to her clients. She is known for confidently managing complex transactions and bringing clarity, professionalism, and care to every step of the process.
In a world where trust matters more than ever, Carrie leads with integrity and heart. She provides honest guidance, clear communication, and a personalized experience that ensures her clients feel supported, protected, and confident from start to finish.
Rooted in Northwest Indiana, Carrie comes from a farm family with ties to some of the area’s early settlers. She was raised on values of hard work, humility, and doing things the right way—principles that continue to guide her business today. It’s this foundation that allows her to build lasting relationships grounded in trust, integrity, and heart.
Carrie is proud of the role she plays within The Jana Caudill Team, bringing a high level of dedication, strategy, and client care to every listing she represents. Her focus is simple: deliver exceptional results while creating an experience that feels seamless, professional, and truly client-first.
If you’re looking for a trusted, high-performing agent who leads with integrity, communicates with clarity, and delivers with heart—Carrie is ready to help you make your next move with confidence.
Our Team

Nicole Plemons
NWI Listing Manager

Jana Caudill
Team Leader / Indiana Real Estate Broker

Melissa Knipper
Executive Assistant / Agent Success Liaison

Vanessa Corning
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Joan Haresco
NWI Closing Manager

Lauren Detamore
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Sheila Chandler
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Jan Margiotta
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Helen Smith
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Ryan Hoskins
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Lynnette Terry
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Pamela Raby
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Amy Wignall
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Casey Bucenell
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Haley Elliott
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Stephen Carr
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Estelle Blockoms
Indiana Real Estate Broker

Dennis Caudill
Commercial Group Director / Indiana Real Estate Broker

Lana Lods
Interior Designer & Home Stylist

Sue Remble
Client & Transaction Success Manager

Cindy Keough
Sales Associate

Tess Scarborough
Sales Associate
